Procedures for urinating while squatting

QUESTION:

Assalamu’alaikum Ustadz permission, I once saw a video from the cleric who explained how to get rid of the sunnah, he said he urinated his right leg while his left leg was revealed, and 3 times, like how to urinate taught by the Prophet … (+62 823-7083-xxxx)

ANSWER

Wa’alaikumussalam warahmatullah wabarakatuh

There is no authentic hadith about this procedure. Narrated from Suraqah bin Malik, he said:

God’s messenger, may God give him up and give him peace, teach us in the open to sit on the left, and put right

The Messenger of Allah (hopefully peace on it) teaches us (manners) at our destination, so that we can sit on his left foot and uphold his right foot. (HR. Al Baihaqi, Imam Ibn Hajar said Dhaif, in Maram)

So that this is free, it can be in such a way, and it can also be more comfortable for someone and more avoiding unclean splashes.
There is also a thunderous thickening there is no sunnah from the Prophet ﷺ. Some scholars say heretics and feed such as Ibn Taimiyah, Al Qaradhawi, etc. Others encourage with the intention that urine can be completed.

Bak by squatting and standing, both of them have been done by the Prophet ﷺ. Everything is authentic. Some friends also stand. It’s just that squat is more important and more often the Prophet ﷺ did not stand up. Some friends also make up. From Hudzaifah Radhiallahu ‘anhu, he said:

The Prophet came to a group of people, and he came standing up and then called with water, so I came to him with water, and he performed

Prophet ﷺ went to a landfill belonging to a people, then he urinated standing. Then he asked for water, so I brought him water and he did not ablution. (HR. Muttafaq ‘alaih)

Imam Ibnul Mundzir said, as collected by Imam An Nawawi:

It was proven by the authority of Umar bin Al -Khattab, Zaid bin Thabit, Ibn Omar, and Sahl bin Saad, that they were a resurrection.

Has Sahih from Umar bin Al Khathab, Zaid bin Tsabit, Ibn Umar, Sahl bin Sa’ad, that they were urinating, it was also narrate from Anas, Ali, Abu Hurairah, it was also done by ibn Sirin, ‘Urwah bin Az Zubeir, While Mas’ud, Ibrahim bin Sa’ad, The Urine Is Standing. (Al Minhaj Syarh Sahih Muslim, 3/166, see also Syarh Abi David, 1/93)

Al Hafizh Ibn Hajar said:

It is clear that he did it to show his passport and urine more urine about qawal, and God knows the best

The truth is that this action (urine) is possible and most of the conditions (the Prophet) urinate while sitting. Wallahu a’lam (Fathul Bari, 1/330)

Imam Ibnul Mundzir also said:

This urine is sitting, I like to be allowed, and all this is determined from the messenger of God, may God give him up and give him peace

I was sitting because I liked it and because I could stand up, all of this was the authentic of the Prophet ﷺ. (Collected by Imam An Nawawi, Al Minhaj Syarh Sahih Muslim, 3/166)

Imam Asy Syaukani said:

(And conclusions) that urine has been determined and sitting, and everyone is a year

Wal results, that it has been authentic from the Prophet urinating standing and sitting, and each is the sunnah. (Nailul Authar, 1/107)

Some even say that urinary standing is actually safer than unclean, such as the words of Umar bin Al Khathab Radhiallahu ‘Anhu, quoted by Imam Ibnul Mundzir below:

This is that the state is based on mourning from tuberculosis and Islam. And this says about Omar

And that, urine pays more attention to the anus and is safer than hadat. This speech was narrated from Umar. (Al Awsath Fis Sunan Wal Ijma ‘Wal Ikhtilaf No. 252)

Some of the scholars who put to standing urine, such as Ibn Mas’ud, Asy Sya’bi, and Ibrahim bin Sa’ad. (Imam An Nawawi, Al Minhaj Syarh Shahih Muslim, 3/166)

Thus. Wallahu a’lam

✍️ Farid Nu’man Hasan

Related